nobletsCostco gold restock alerts
Back to the blog

Investing in Physical Gold: A Beginner's Guide

Bars or coins, what you pay over spot, where to keep it, and how it's taxed.

Beginner Guide5 min read

A gold bar and a folded slip of white paper on navy paper against a pale blue wall.

What Owning Physical Gold Means

Physical gold means bars and coins you own outright and can hold. Gold ETFs and mining stocks track the price without putting metal in your hands. Owning the metal costs more along the way: you pay a premium over spot to buy, accept a dealer's lower bid to sell, and handle storage and insurance in between.

Gold pays no interest or dividends, so your return is the price change minus those costs. This guide covers the basic choices and what they cost. It's general information, not investment advice.

Gold Bars vs. Coins

Bars usually cost the least over spot per ounce. Coins cost more, but government bullion coins like the American Eagle, American Buffalo and Canadian Maple Leaf are known to nearly every dealer, which makes them easy to sell. Size matters as much as format: the smaller the piece, the higher the premium per ounce of gold.

Costco's prices, tracked by noblets in early 2025, show the pattern. Its 1 oz and larger bars targeted about 2 to 2.5% over spot, 1 oz Eagles and Buffalos 4 to 5%, and 10 g and 25 g bars 10% or more. Dealer premiums vary by dealer and over time, so compare the percentage over spot, not the price tag.

Proof and collector coins are a different product. Their prices depend on rarity and condition as well as gold content, so they cost well over melt value and aren't a cheap way to own gold.

A gold bar and a gold coin in a clear capsule on either side of a seam between pale blue and navy paper.

Purity and Weight

Most modern bars, Maple Leafs and American Buffalos are .9999 fine, meaning 99.99% gold. The American Eagle is 22 karat: 91.67% gold, with silver and copper added for hardness. It still holds a full troy ounce of gold; the coin itself weighs more, about 1.09 troy ounces.

Gold is weighed in troy ounces of 31.1 grams, heavier than an ordinary ounce, and bars also come in grams. A 1 oz bar or coin is the usual middle ground: its premium is close to the large-bar rate, and you can sell one piece at a time. Bigger bars (100 g, 10 oz, 1 kg) cost less over spot, but you have to sell them whole.

Storage and Insurance

Keeping gold at home costs nothing up front but carries theft risk, and a standard homeowners policy covers little of it. The widely used ISO homeowners form sets a special theft limit of $200 for money, bullion and coins. Insurers offer endorsements or scheduled coverage to raise it, so read your own policy and ask before assuming you're covered.

A bank safe deposit box keeps gold out of the house, but the contents aren't FDIC insured and banks generally don't pay for theft or damage, so you still need your own coverage. Private depositories store and insure metal for an annual fee, usually priced as a percentage of value. They make more sense for larger holdings than for a few coins.

Taxes and Reporting

In the US, the IRS treats gold bullion and coins as collectibles. A profit on gold held more than a year is taxed at a maximum federal rate of 28%, rather than the lower long-term rates that apply to stocks. Gold held a year or less produces a short-term gain, taxed as ordinary income.

Keep the receipt for every purchase: the date and price set your gain when you sell. Separately, a business that receives more than $10,000 in cash in one transaction or related transactions must file IRS Form 8300; card payments, wires and personal checks don't count as cash for that rule. Your own situation and state rules matter, so check with a tax professional.

Key Takeaways

A short checklist for buying physical gold the first time:

Before your first purchase:

  • Compare prices as a percentage over spot, wherever you buy.
  • Start with 1 oz bars or government bullion coins; small pieces carry the highest premiums per ounce.
  • Skip proof and collector coins unless you collect.
  • Buy from established sellers (Costco, large online dealers, reputable coin shops), and be careful with private sales and marketplaces, where counterfeits turn up.
  • Know where you'll sell before you buy: Costco doesn't buy gold back, so selling means a dealer's bid.
  • Plan your storage and check your insurance limits for bullion and coins.
  • Keep every receipt for tax purposes.

None of this says whether to buy gold or how much to hold. It's about not overpaying once you've decided to.

Where to Start

Physical gold is easy to buy and costs more to hold than many people expect: a premium going in, a spread coming out, and storage in between. Over a long holding period those costs shrink against the price of gold. Over a short one they can wipe out a gain. Start small, compare premiums, and decide how you'll store and sell before you buy. This is general information, not investment advice.